Reply
Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Daniel Doerksen's Avatar
Old (#1)
Hey guys working on this modular building/environment and im looking for some helpful crits



Last edited by Daniel Doerksen; 01-18-2010 at 01:57 PM..
Offline , spline, 108 Posts, Join Date Nov 2009,  
   Reply With Quote

ZacD's Avatar
Old (#2)
Very clean (texture and modeling well done), nice job with the sand, looks nice.
Offline , polycounter, lvl. 13, 7,245 Posts, Join Date Jul 2009, Location Columbus Ohio Send a message via MSN to ZacD  
   Reply With Quote

turpedo's Avatar
Old (#3)
Nice colors, I like the mountain range you did.

I don't know if it is just my eyes playing tricks on me, but the metal cylinder closest to the camera in the first shot looks a little stretched. The bolts look more like ovals than circles. Could just be my eyes though!
Offline , triangle, 326 Posts, Join Date Oct 2008, Location Irvine, California  
   Reply With Quote

Progg's Avatar
Old (#4)
Is this from the Orion mod?
Steven Skidmore - Environment Artist - Crytek USA
Offline , polycounter, 902 Posts, Join Date Sep 2009, Location Austin, Texas Send a message via MSN to Progg  
   Reply With Quote

Daniel Doerksen's Avatar
Old (#5)
Thanks for the comments,

the assets from this scene will be used in orion, this is part of my contributions to the mod, the scene will hopefully be in my portfolio.

im gonna check into the stretching a bit later see what the problem is.
Offline , spline, 108 Posts, Join Date Nov 2009,  
   Reply With Quote

PredatorGSR's Avatar
Old (#6)
I really like the lighting and texturing in the scene. Nice job.
Konrad Beerbaum: Environment Artist
http://www.konradbeerbaum.com
Offline , polygon, 621 Posts, Join Date Jan 2010, Location Austin, TX  
   Reply With Quote

DnS's Avatar
Old (#7)
Looks really good.

There is a strange gap at the roof line in the top image above the solid metal wall.

Also, if some of those windows are broken, you'd probably see some broken glass on the ground.
Offline , line, 67 Posts, Join Date May 2007, Location Boston, MA  
   Reply With Quote

Daniel Doerksen's Avatar
Old (#8)
good point on the broken glass, i should definitly add that in there. that gap you noticed is with the the modularity of the pieces not lining up i havent made enough filler pieces to adjust for every given situation
Offline , spline, 108 Posts, Join Date Nov 2009,  
   Reply With Quote

Spitfire's Avatar
Old (#9)
Great start!

Could use alot more stuff in and around the building to make it feel more "filled up"
Really nice style on it so far, just needs more!
Offline , triangle, 310 Posts, Join Date Aug 2009, Location Stockholm Sweden  
   Reply With Quote

rollin's Avatar
Old (#10)
give the sand some more nm-love.. this stands out the most so far
Offline , card carrying polycounter, 2,149 Posts, Join Date Oct 2004, Location munich, germany  
   Reply With Quote

efren_chavez's Avatar
Old (#11)
I like the normal maps on the metal pillar in the front of the building.
Things that would be nice to see:
In the first image (shot taken in the front of the structure) it would be nice to see some foreground element to create a more interesting composition and define the spatial relationship between the viewer and the structure.
The inside of the building looks a bit empty, you probably want to convey a sense of this building having been abandoned for quite some time, but even then it would be nice to see some objects inside that point out towards what the purpose of this place is/was.
The small spotlight/lamps on the top of the structure look too clean compared to the rest of the structure. It would make sense for a couple of them to be broken or fallen. Also the glass should be dusty/cloudy just like the glass in the windows.
Like it has been said before, maybe few pieces of glass in the floor would be nice.
Other than that I think is a good piece of work. Please post the finished product when you are done.
Offline , null, 6 Posts, Join Date Jan 2010, Location San Diego, CA, USA  
   Reply With Quote

Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Copyright 1998-2012 A. Risch