Author : Nate Broach


Reply
Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Sir_KnowS's Avatar
Old (#1)
Greetings,
I've been working on my online portfolio and resume in preparation for job hunting.Here's my gallery.
Here's my resume . There's a link at the bottom of the page to see it in a .doc form.

critiques? comments?
Offline , null, 10 Posts, Join Date Jan 2005,  
   Reply With Quote

Sectaurs's Avatar
Old (#2)
thumbnails are too small.

you don't seem to have any texture flats shown?

you've a nice painterly style, though it approaches being too simple on a couple pieces.
Roböt - The Company - 3D Prototypes and Prints

Lead Artist - Stomp Games
Offline , veteran polycounter, 3,848 Posts, Join Date Oct 2004, Location Maynard, MA Send a message via AIM to Sectaurs  
   Reply With Quote

Xenobond's Avatar
Old (#3)
OMG! Not the futuristic car from hell!

You should totally finish up that Bronx texture.
Kurtis Smith
Senior Artist - Petroglyph Games
Offline , dedicated polycounter, 1,885 Posts, Join Date Nov 2005, Location Las Vegas, NV  
   Reply With Quote

cholden's Avatar
Old (#4)
No Splash, No News (Updates page), Gallery = index (main page)

Real thumbnails, no cropped sections

Remove info next to thumbnails, leave the info on the full image page

Organize thumbnails into standard rows and columns. (2 rows of 4 columns would be best)

Navigate can be improved by adding link to next image on the full sized images (For example, if I click blunderbuss image, it loads hatchet page, and so on...)

Details, such as tricount, texture sheets and sizes, dev time, etc. are always nice.

Remove 2d Gallery

On Resume page put RESUME first, then Q&A after.

Q&A is titled "3D GALLERY"

Overall, your work is clean and has a nice painted appearance, but nothing really stands out as a serious piece that defines your skill. Such as, a full character or full environment (which ever direction you want to go most)
Offline , veteran polycounter, 3,303 Posts, Join Date Oct 2004, Location Denver, CO Send a message via ICQ to cholden  
   Reply With Quote

pliang's Avatar
Old (#5)
I also think some actual lighting instead of apparent real time viewport grabs would be good.
Portfolio: http://peterliang.wordpress.com/

CG Generalist available for work.
Offline , card carrying polycounter, 2,094 Posts, Join Date May 2006, Location Canada Send a message via MSN to pliang  
   Reply With Quote

Spug's Avatar
Old (#6)
weapons are top notch! reminds me so much of TF2. Im let down though by your characters and your car. Although it seems you have great work...on a plain website. Make the actual website more interesting and reflect your artistic talents. Keep it up though...i like your style a lot
www.carbinestudios.com

www.wildstar-online.com/en/

Senior 3D Artist - Carbine Studios
Offline , triangle, 360 Posts, Join Date Jul 2007, Location Orange County CA Send a message via AIM to Spug Send a message via MSN to Spug  
   Reply With Quote

Sir_KnowS's Avatar
Old (#7)
thx for all the input
Ill get to work on your suggestions
Offline , null, 10 Posts, Join Date Jan 2005,  
   Reply With Quote

systmh's Avatar
Old (#8)
hah! the ZF1. i want it. does it fold up like in the movie?
Offline , line, 74 Posts, Join Date Feb 2007, Location NYC  
   Reply With Quote

okkun's Avatar
Old (#9)
loose the car, it's not your best work
-oKKun

VALKYRIE ENTERTAINMENT

Always looking for talented artists - on site Seattle or freelance
Offline , polygon, 572 Posts, Join Date Jan 2005, Location Seattle WA  
   Reply With Quote

Acord's Avatar
Old (#10)
Zoomed in thumbnails are not good, and your thumbnails are too small to give a good idea of what we're seeing. Make the thumbnails bigger, and they need to include the whole picture.

Lose the car, or at least do your own texturing for it.

Lose the WiP - if this is your portfolio, don't include unfinished work. People might get the wrong idea about your work ethic.

Make sure you put your name and email address on your images. That way, if someone wonders across it(like doing an image search in google) they can be lazy and already know how to contact you.

Lose the ambient lighting on the models. They're too bright, and contrast will bring out the details.

Center the web page - on a high res screen, it tends towards the left side.

Put your contact information right on the web page. Users are lazy, and you should show them any information that they want right off the bat.

Make sure that the text you add in your images is SEO kosher. And once you're done with your page, don't forget to submit it into the search engines.

Looks good so far - I love that gun. Fifth Element? [img]/images/graemlins/wink.gif[/img]
Offline , vertex, 32 Posts, Join Date Oct 2007,  
   Reply With Quote

Sir_KnowS's Avatar
Old (#11)
cholden
there is a splash page, I just directed the link straight to my portfolio. Here's the start page
I'm leaning towards an environment artist position. Last I heard the industry needed these artists and it would be a good way to break in.

systmh, Acord,
the ZF1, from the Fifth Element, does open up. I haven't uploaded the movie yet.
Offline , null, 10 Posts, Join Date Jan 2005,  
   Reply With Quote

moose's Avatar
Old (#12)
If you're interested in doing environment art, potential employers who visit your site will want to see environment art samples you have created. Your gallery consists of weapons, a creature, and a car. without reading your posts here, i would have no idea environment art would be of any interest to you.

Id combine the six shooters, for a second, i thought they were the same piece just duplicated; one as a wip and one as a final.

The first two textured pieces are cool, but the rest of the portfolio doesn't live up to them.

for the site, im not a fan of the colors, the green and yellow is a bit garish. but, whatever floats yer boat. The header does not continue to the right edge of the window in firefox

In the about me, write it like an artist statement, not a Q&A. It's a definite plus to be avid about games when creating them, but imo isn't something that will get you a job because you read manuals that come with games [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img] If anything, i'd lose that section entirely from your resume, and move it to a specific "personal" section. Even there, I would write about yourself without giving yourself a Q&A.

in your updates, you have a bunch of old news, with information that doesnt exist on the site anymore. delete that stuff! IE, you can click on the highpoly girl link and get a demoreel button at the top, but it doesnt exist anywhere else.

get some more finished content up there, build up a strong portfolio from those finished pieces, and you'll be good to go.
Offline , card carrying polycounter, 2,297 Posts, Join Date Oct 2004, Location Cary, NC Send a message via ICQ to moose Send a message via AIM to moose Send a message via MSN to moose  
   Reply With Quote

Mr Smo's Avatar
Old (#13)
Offline , triangle, 270 Posts, Join Date Oct 2004, Location Canada  
   Reply With Quote

commander_keen's Avatar
Old (#14)
The thumbnails are really bad. Your work is 10 times better then they lead the viewer to think.
Offline , polygon, 616 Posts, Join Date Jan 2005, Location Los Gatos, CA  
   Reply With Quote

Jeremy Lindstrom's Avatar
Old (#15)
Also, if you are going to have an 'update' page actually update it, says it hasn't been updated since March which would make us believe you haven't done any 3D work in many many months.
Artist formerly known as Dekard
Portfolio Sketchbook Environment Wiki
Offline , veteran polycounter, 2,661 Posts, Join Date Nov 2004, Location Lewisville, TX Send a message via ICQ to Jeremy Lindstrom Send a message via AIM to Jeremy Lindstrom Send a message via MSN to Jeremy Lindstrom  
   Reply With Quote

pliang's Avatar
Old (#16)
Changing the date would work...actually don't do that
Portfolio: http://peterliang.wordpress.com/

CG Generalist available for work.
Offline , card carrying polycounter, 2,094 Posts, Join Date May 2006, Location Canada Send a message via MSN to pliang  
   Reply With Quote

3DGURU's Avatar
Old (#17)
an error shows and says [don't send] , lol ...
Offline , Banned, 117 Posts, Join Date Jun 2006, Location Jordan  
   Reply With Quote

Acord's Avatar
Old (#18)
Better not to include dates etc, unless a large body of your work is apparently very old and you want to sort of archive it.
Offline , vertex, 32 Posts, Join Date Oct 2007,  
   Reply With Quote

danpants's Avatar
Old (#19)
Nice work. I agree the thumbnails are too small. I didn't like having to click the gallery button to look at another image. Your modeling is great, nice and clean. Your textures are good but I think that you might adjust the lighting it looks like your images could really be improved if you just adjust the levels. And really bring out the colors.
I'd say more like one out of a million.
So you're telling me there's a chance.

Website: http://www.danpants.com/
Offline , line, 71 Posts, Join Date Oct 2007, Location San Diego, Ca  
   Reply With Quote

Sir_KnowS's Avatar
Old (#20)
Happy Holidays,
thanks for the comments. I've given the website a new look and changed the way I display my models. For instance here's the ZF-1.
And here's an example of the ZF-1 opening.

Also I've reworked Bronx some. Here's a rigging test/walk cycle of the new model.
Offline , null, 10 Posts, Join Date Jan 2005,  
   Reply With Quote

rooster's Avatar
Old (#21)
have you changed the thumbnails? they're pretty annoying, I have no idea what I'm going to see when I click them
www.redprodukt.com
Rich Make Game! twitter: @RichMakeGame
"You can't edit nothing"
Offline , Counter of Polys™, 6,426 Posts, Join Date Dec 2004, Location Newcastle, uk  
   Reply With Quote

TheMadArtist's Avatar
Old (#22)
Lose the About Me section ENTIRELY. It just comes off unprofessional, like you're interviewing yourself. None of that is relevant at all, except the education question, which is included in the actual resume. I would also take off Hardcore Gamer from the top of your profile. Again, it just looks unprofessional.
Offline , polycounter, 802 Posts, Join Date Mar 2007, Location SugarLand TX  
   Reply With Quote

ryuju's Avatar
Old (#23)
your UT mod link takes you to the Polycount page
Offline , line, 63 Posts, Join Date Jan 2007, Location State College, PA  
   Reply With Quote

shotgun's Avatar
Old (#24)
I played with your self portrait, hope u dont mind


I think your work's very clean, very well articulated, but doesn't show me the best you've got. You can push some of the textures and equal them in terms of detail to your 3d geometry. In its current form, your portfolio is solid but small and lacks a punch.

I don't think you need to scrap the about section (although asking questions is an odd way to give answers). If you have something to say - just say it.
The avatar tells all
Offline , dedicated polycounter, 1,887 Posts, Join Date Nov 2004, Location Israel Send a message via ICQ to shotgun  
   Reply With Quote

rasmus's Avatar
Old (#25)
Nice clean and stylized texturing and modeling there, like it. Overall pagedesign is not that good-looking though, and the Q&A is a bit wonky. Thumbnails are too zoomed-in to be informative. Skip the splash-screen. "About" page is a bit big maybe. Would be nice to see some more work, too! Maybe other types, different styles?

Cheers,
Rasmus Deguchi - LinkedIn
Independent Game Developer
www.razkun.com
Offline , polycounter, 810 Posts, Join Date Dec 2007, Location Tokyo, Japan  
   Reply With Quote

Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Copyright 1998-2012 A. Risch