Author : Nate Broach


Reply
Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
mr_ace's Avatar
Old (#1)
Hey Everyone, I've been working on this guy on and off for the last couple of months. I'm allllmost done with the high poly, just a couple of little things that have been bothering me, along with any crits you guys make.

Progress wise, I've made the low poly and I'm just finalising the uv's, then I'm going to polypaint most of the parts then finish up the textures in PS.

Anyway, please let me know what you think and any crits you've got would be really helpful.

Cheers

I think I got a bit carried away with the background of the render....





CURRENT PROGRESS:






Last edited by mr_ace; 10-17-2012 at 06:07 PM..
Offline , triangle, 394 Posts, Join Date Feb 2009, Location Belfast  
   Reply With Quote

ysalex's Avatar
Old (#2)
Damn. Really great cloth modeling here. The face, where the nose connects to the brow and the eyes corner their way into that whole deal, could use some work. Also he seems to be a fairly average build, but he has a super fat neck. It exists in the real world, but it doesn't read great here.

Still though: damn. Well done.
Offline , polygon, 731 Posts, Join Date Aug 2011, Location Seattle  
   Reply With Quote

Tobbo's Avatar
Old (#3)
The attention to detail is great. Looking forward to seeing him textured.
Offline , spline, 203 Posts, Join Date Dec 2011,  
   Reply With Quote

snake85027's Avatar
Old (#4)
the detail is amzing, great folds.
Looking for work.
www.dwbailey.com
Offline , triangle, 447 Posts, Join Date Dec 2005, Location phoenix Send a message via AIM to snake85027 Send a message via MSN to snake85027 Send a message via Yahoo to snake85027  
   Reply With Quote

buhtichka's Avatar
Old (#5)
wow! ... amazing ...
Offline , null, 6 Posts, Join Date Feb 2012, Location Sofia, Bulgaria  
   Reply With Quote

mr_ace's Avatar
Old (#6)
ysalex: yea i'm not too happy with the face, it definately needs some small tweaks before i bake it. I'll have a look at the neck, if it's too big I'm probably going to scale it down in the lowpoly as it'll only be a pretty small tweak, I was going for a pretty big build guy though.

Tobbom snake and buhtichka: thanks a lot, really kind of you guys
Offline , triangle, 394 Posts, Join Date Feb 2009, Location Belfast  
   Reply With Quote

Snader's Avatar
Old (#7)
The face is fighting with itself in terms of weight. You've given him a somewhat pudgy look, but at the same time have strongly defined cheekbones. This is what causes the top half of the face to look skinny but the lower half (+ neck) to look fat. I'd make the neck and chin a bit less chubby, and the cheekbones softer to come at an average shape of mildly fat.

His thumb looks rather short, too, and the cap and shoe-noses a bit large.
Geospheres rule, regular spheres drool!
Offline , card carrying polycounter, 2,247 Posts, Join Date Jan 2008, Location the Netherlands (Europe)  
   Reply With Quote

woogity's Avatar
Old (#8)
Thumb mouth and nose feel a bit on the tiny side, the detailing on the clothes is really really nice man! esp the jacket.
"The blacksmith and the artist reflect it in thier art. Forge their creativity closer to the heart YEAH! Its closer to the heart!"






Vageta whats your scouter read about this model?


ITS OVER NINE THOUSAND!!!!!!!
Offline , dedicated polycounter, 1,542 Posts, Join Date Sep 2008, Location Brighton, UK  
   Reply With Quote

Ravanna's Avatar
Old (#9)
Visually it works, I can easily imagine him killing a hooker with a hammer. Great work
http://ravanna.wix.com/portfolio

Eeels up inside 'ya
Offline , spline, 155 Posts, Join Date Sep 2011, Location South West England Send a message via Skype™ to Ravanna  
   Reply With Quote

afisher's Avatar
Old (#10)
Great work man! some really nice folds. The weight/ fat distribution seems off on the face though. the top half of the face seems like an average build and the lower half a fatter build. I'd also look at widening the nose slightly. The chest looks a bit bare compare to the neck (in terms of detail/form), but I'm just nitpicking. Kick ass work, can't wait to see the low poly and some bakes.
Freelance Artist
afisher.com.au - CGHub
Offline , triangle, 359 Posts, Join Date Jul 2010, Location Australia Send a message via Skype™ to afisher  
   Reply With Quote

barnesy's Avatar
Old (#11)
Great work, I agree with with what everyone else has said.

I have a tiny nit picky comment. It seems like the compression folds on the boots, especially the back left boot, seem to be off. It seems to look like the same material as the trouser cloth on that angle.

Other than that , awesome work!
3D Artist looking for work

Portfolio - www.mikebarnes3d.com

Evil Winston Churchill WIP
Offline , triangle, 432 Posts, Join Date Feb 2010, Location Liskeard Cornwall  
   Reply With Quote

MGM's Avatar
Old (#12)
Very nice. Live sculpt
Offline , line, 61 Posts, Join Date Dec 2010, Location Saint-Petersburg  
   Reply With Quote

marcinLDZ's Avatar
Old (#13)
Amazing work.
Offline , null, 5 Posts, Join Date Apr 2012, Location Poland  
   Reply With Quote

Jeremy Tabor's Avatar
Old (#14)
Very nice sense of scale with all of the detailing. Makes it feel very realistic. Great Job!

Like others have said, the ratios of the hand seem off. The thumb is stubby, yes, but I also would say the medial phalanges of the index and Middle fingers are a little long too. Here are a couple observations I've made (and I'm sure so many others have made as well) which help me maintain nice human looking hands and keep away from E.T. or Chimp hands, lol:

Take a look at this xray of the hand. Speaking in general terms, the proximal phalanx of each of the fingers is almost the length of the medial and distal combined. So in this model's case, I don't think that ratio is matching up quite right. And then, once the finger length is established, the tip of the thumb will normally fall within the second half of the proximal phalanx of the index finger when swung up beside it. There is a bit of variance to that thumb rule, I've seen. For instance, my thumb is longer and lines up with the second knuckle, however, I know people with that "toe-thumb" thing going on, and they have a similar ratio as your model does. So really, I guess what you have currently with the thumb and length of fingers is within the realm of possibility respectively, but when combined; short thumb with long fingers, it looks strange.

Last edited by Jeremy Tabor; 07-01-2012 at 09:40 AM..
Jeremy Tabor
(Freshly unemployed and lookin for work!)
Offline , triangle, 491 Posts, Join Date Mar 2010, Location Los Angeles, CA  
   Reply With Quote

El Scorcho's Avatar
Old (#15)
Looks great dude, especially the folds on his clothes and skin. His face looks younger than I would expect from a trucker. I think it's the size of the eyes and mouth that are causing that.
Holdeen's Elf Girl Done

Portfolio

Available for full-time or freelance
Offline , line, 78 Posts, Join Date Nov 2007, Location Dallas  
   Reply With Quote

Alberto Rdrgz's Avatar
Old (#16)
You have such great detail, all throughout this character, but the face is falling short. I agree that it looks like a mix between a normal Guy and a fat one. Something weird is happening around the eyes, also break up the smoothness with wrinkles, pimples, scars, pores, what have you. But great job overall man, kudos!!
- Environment Work - [Art Dump] [CGHUB]

Ready at Dawn Studios - [Esc Challenge]
Offline , card carrying polycounter, 2,248 Posts, Join Date Jul 2009, Location Irvine, CA. Send a message via Skype™ to Alberto Rdrgz  
   Reply With Quote

mr_ace's Avatar
Old (#17)
Hey everyone, thanks for all the great crits.

I've been on holiday for the last week so haven't got as much done as I would like, but I'm trucking along (GET IT?)... Here's some texture progress, I'm having a seperate sheet for the head and arms etc, so just clothes. I've only just blocked in the feet, they need plenty of work, I'll post up better shots when I get more done.

As for the head, a lot of you guys were not feeling the head at all, so I think I'm probably going to re-do it completely, I reckon it'll be a better learning experience that way.



Let me know what you think so far, all crits welcome. Thanks a lot

EDIT: Just realised I haven't posted any wires or anything either, I'll post those up when i make a bit more texture progress too...
Offline , triangle, 394 Posts, Join Date Feb 2009, Location Belfast  
   Reply With Quote

JohnnyCrespo's Avatar
Old (#18)
Looking pretty awesome. Good details.
Offline , vertex, 44 Posts, Join Date Sep 2011, Location LA  
   Reply With Quote

Two Listen's Avatar
Old (#19)
Ooooh. Nice material definition.
Offline , polycounter, 1,046 Posts, Join Date Dec 2008,  
   Reply With Quote

ScudzAlmighty's Avatar
Old (#20)
that gif is making me dizzy, pretty groovy though
not too sure about how the skirt is only half-tucked, but then stuck behind the belt buckle, that feels a little unnatural.
Online , card carrying polycounter, 2,471 Posts, Join Date Apr 2009, Location Vancouver BC  
   Reply With Quote

OrganizedChaos's Avatar
Old (#21)
Looks neat so far! I'm really digging the folds you've got going on. Just curious- what was your inspiration behind this?
Offline , polygon, 726 Posts, Join Date Jan 2007, Location Austin, TX  
   Reply With Quote

Rion411's Avatar
Old (#22)
wow, looks awesome! Textures are lookin' nice.
Offline , triangle, 324 Posts, Join Date May 2005, Location Albuquerque, NM  
   Reply With Quote

Fred2303's Avatar
Old (#23)
Looks killer!! good job!
http://Miaw3d.com[B]
Character Artist At Eidos
Offline , triangle, 476 Posts, Join Date Apr 2011, Location Montreal  
   Reply With Quote

Fred2303's Avatar
Old (#24)
just noticed that the leather boots seems a bit too specular/glossy for some hold working boots.

also for the coat you could add alot of details in your gloss map by making by making the light borwn/beige spots less glossy.

if you could psot you maps it could be great!

great job again!
http://Miaw3d.com[B]
Character Artist At Eidos
Offline , triangle, 476 Posts, Join Date Apr 2011, Location Montreal  
   Reply With Quote

whw's Avatar
Old (#25)
Nice eay subject this one, good to see it taking shape.

I'd say the folds around the sleeves could do with another pass as it appears like a rubber suit the way some of the folds intersect. And I'm in full agreement with Fred2303 regarding the specular values - tone them down as that's adding to that rubber/plastic feel.

For ideas on where you could take the materials, check out this model: http://josemlazaro.com/blog/wp-conte...011/04/Ben.jpg
Offline , line, 81 Posts, Join Date Apr 2009, Location UK  
   Reply With Quote

Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Copyright 1998-2012 A. Risch