Home General Discussion

EA Closes Mythic

polycounter lvl 9
Offline / Send Message
skyline5gtr polycounter lvl 9
Another bites the dust, sorry to all

http://www.ign.com/articles/2014/05/29/ea-closes-mythic-entertainment

True or not this made me chuckle

get?url=https%3A%2F%2Fscontent-a.xx.fbcdn.net%2Fhphotos-xpa1%2Ft1.0-9%2F1380046_740280542659580_457664629580523390_n.png&key=LgnJDtLcXegCnoZSMjyf-g&w=800&h=213

Replies

  • Torch
    Offline / Send Message
    Torch interpolator
    *Remembers good old days of War Online*

    *Vendetta against EA intensifies*
  • Isaiah Sherman
    Offline / Send Message
    Isaiah Sherman polycounter lvl 14
    Warhammer Online died a while ago, but I had some great times in that game.

    The use of player physics to block other players was actually fantastic in that game.

    Get a bunch of tanks to literally block off an area and the other team could could not physically pass w/out killing them.


    RIP :(
  • eld
    Offline / Send Message
    eld polycounter lvl 18
    It's a shame, Mythic could have been behind bringing back both ultima and dungeon keeper back to life but ended up suffering from monetization choices.
  • skyline5gtr
    Offline / Send Message
    skyline5gtr polycounter lvl 9
    incase anyone is keeping track

    Original HQ in San Mateo, California, moved to Redwood City in 1998.
    Origin Systems in Austin, Texas founded in 1983, acquired in 1992, closed in 2004.
    Bullfrog Productions in Surrey, England, founded in 1987, acquired in 1995, merged with EA UK and effectively closed in 2001.
    EA Baltimore in Baltimore, Maryland, established in 1996 as part of Origin, closed in 2000
    EA Seattle in Seattle, Washington, founded in 1982 as Manley & Associates, acquired January 29, 1996, closed in 2002
    Maxis in Walnut Creek, California, founded in 1987, acquired in June 1997, folded into Redwood Shores (now Visceral Games) in 2004
    Westwood Studios in Las Vegas, Nevada, founded in 1987, acquired from Virgin Interactive Entertainment in August 1998, merged into EA Los Angeles in 2003.
    EA Pacific (known for a time as Westwood Pacific) in Irvine, California, formerly part of Virgin Interactive, acquired with Westwood in 1998, closed in 2003
    Kesmai (known also as GameStorm), founded in 1981, acquired in 1999, closed in 2001.
    DICE Canada in London, Ontario, started in 1998, acquired DICE fully October 2, 2006; closed DICE Canada studio hours later.
    EA Japan in Tokyo, Japan, closed due to consolidation; moved under EA Partners model
    EA UK in Chertsey, United Kingdom, moved to EA UK in Guildford
    EA Chicago in Hoffman Estates, Illinois, founded in 1990 as NuFX, acquired in 2004, closed November 6, 2007.
    Pandemic Studios in Los Angeles, California and Brisbane, Queensland, Australia, founded in 1998, acquired October 2007 from Elevation Partners, closed November 17, 2009.
    Bright Light, in Guildford, Surrey, formerly EA UK, closed in 2011.
    EA Mobile in S
  • fmnoor
    Offline / Send Message
    fmnoor polycounter lvl 17
    "Maxis in Walnut Creek, California, founded in 1987, acquired in June 1997, folded into Redwood Shores (now Visceral Games) in 2004"

    This is not correct. Where did you get this information from exactly?
  • StephenVyas
    Offline / Send Message
    StephenVyas polycounter lvl 18
    It's interesting to see the average lifespan of a company after an EA acquisition.
  • skyline5gtr
    Offline / Send Message
    skyline5gtr polycounter lvl 9
    Got the info from wikipedia, not exactly the most reliable source i guess
  • iconoplast
    Offline / Send Message
    iconoplast polycounter lvl 13
    Probably just some confusion -- 2004 was when the physical location of the Maxis studio changed to that location. Maxis itself still exists though.
  • skylebones
    Offline / Send Message
    skylebones polycounter lvl 10
    That list is heartbreaking. Hits me right in the nostalgic feel goods.
  • fmnoor
    Offline / Send Message
    fmnoor polycounter lvl 17
    Well, there are multiple Maxis locations, the Walnut Creek studio moved to Emeryville and continues to operate. The Sims comes out of a different division located in RedWood Shores.
  • iconoplast
    Offline / Send Message
    iconoplast polycounter lvl 13
    Ah, I thought it was Walnut Creek that moved to Redwood and Emeryville was the new one. Now I know! (Isn't one of them in Finland? No one ever talks about that one.)

    More on topic, I'm sad that Mythic was shut down and I am utterly unsurprised by it. I'm actually more surprised that it wasn't done earlier given EA's record, but I guess they wanted to let the new Dungeon Keeper finish tanking first.
  • skyline5gtr
    Offline / Send Message
    skyline5gtr polycounter lvl 9
    DK was a terrible game , it was a prime example of why the micro-transaction plan will fail
  • ambershee
    Offline / Send Message
    ambershee polycounter lvl 17
    Got the info from wikipedia, not exactly the most reliable source i guess

    It misses out the studios that still "exist" but are effectively dead with skeleton crews too, for example Criterion in Guildford.
  • Justin Meisse
    Offline / Send Message
    Justin Meisse polycounter lvl 18
    Gets me right in the feels, thanks for giving me and many others a start in this biz, Mythic.
  • almighty_gir
    Offline / Send Message
    almighty_gir ngon master
    WAR was my first MMO addiction, there hasn't been one like it and i doubt there ever will be.

    it's still the only MMO (apart from DAOC, to my knowledge) that didn't have a minimum level for pvp, you could literally start a new character, and queue for pvp instances or run to the rvr lake and start taking names.

    i miss that =[
  • Sean VanGorder
    EA is literally the devil, amirite guys?

    Sorry to everyone at Mythic, I know we're looking for some more people here at Visceral.
  • thomasp
    Offline / Send Message
    thomasp hero character
    "Playfish in London, England, acquired in 2009, closed down in 2013."

    all of playfish closed down, seriously? or just the london studio? they had a few more, after all.
    and my, what a body count...
  • Blaizer
    Offline / Send Message
    Blaizer interpolator
    Their move to mobile games was a bad move. Dungeon keeper for mobile was a total fiasco, so if you think it well, the studio didn't report enough profits, nor with the closed warhammer online (game that compared with korean mmos, were not good enough).

    To innovate with new and good games every 1-3 years or to die, that's the unique way to survive in this industry. All the studios have their days counted, so don't be surprised when id closes.

    There are too many indie devs passing away without further notice, and i totally understand the EA move, because Mythic only represents money losses for them.

    Welcome to this nice indrustry of Nomads :)
  • katana
    Offline / Send Message
    katana polycounter lvl 14
    I hope everyone bounces back fast.
  • ambershee
    Offline / Send Message
    ambershee polycounter lvl 17
    thomasp wrote: »
    "Playfish in London, England, acquired in 2009, closed down in 2013."

    all of playfish closed down, seriously? or just the london studio? they had a few more, after all.
    and my, what a body count...

    Playfish is defunct, so yes, all of Playfish. EA's bodycount over the past few years is frighteningly high.
  • Justin Meisse
    Offline / Send Message
    Justin Meisse polycounter lvl 18
    Blaizer wrote: »
    nor with the closed warhammer online (game that compared with korean mmos, were not good enough).

    Nope, it was because it was based on someone else's IP, that's why DaoC & UO are still running. People forget that Warhammer Online has a pretty good reviews from critics and players: 86 metacritic and 7.6 user score. If the economy didn't tank at the time we all would have gotten fat high rating bonuses because it was in the 90's at launch.
  • CordellC
    Offline / Send Message
    CordellC polycounter lvl 11
    damn

    I really enjoyed Warhammer back in the day
  • Justin Meisse
    Offline / Send Message
    Justin Meisse polycounter lvl 18
    Josh Drescher's post about it
    WAR was my first MMO addiction, there hasn't been one like it and i doubt there ever will be.

    Yup, it's the only MMO I've worked on that I've played for fun for any length of time. Now that I think of it, it's the longest I've played any MMO besides Ultima Online.

    Anyone who lost your job at Mythic today, just remember, you've got a few friends out there in the industry:
    WAR_Group.png
  • doc rob
    Offline / Send Message
    doc rob polycounter lvl 19
    There's a lot of wrong people in this thread.

    1) EA was nothing but good to Mythic. It's been 6 years since WAR came out - 6 YEARS - and Dungeon Keeper was the only thing to come out of the studio in that time to generate revenue. How do you think Mythic stayed afloat that long? EA could have shut it down at any time and kept the live MMOs going with a small crew. EA tried for 6 years to allow Mythic to reinvent itself as a studio, and Dungeon Keeper shows that it was finally getting there.

    2) Dungeon Keeper was a success. For all the hardcore gamer hate, the people that game was actually for, liked it and continue to play it. It's a successful game. Check the app annie gross charts trend if you don't believe me.
  • Bigjohn
    Offline / Send Message
    Bigjohn polycounter lvl 11
    doc rob wrote: »
    Check the app annie gross charts trend if you don't believe me.

    Where can I see that?
  • aesir
    Offline / Send Message
    aesir polycounter lvl 18
    It's interesting to see the average lifespan of a company after an EA acquisition.

    I wish I had the data to compare it to the lifespan of an independent developer, and a developer under other publishers.

    I sincerely doubt places close faster with EA.
  • thomasp
    Offline / Send Message
    thomasp hero character
    aesir wrote: »
    I wish I had the data to compare it to the lifespan of an independent developer, and a developer under other publishers.

    i'd argue independently run places have more of an incentive to keep the business running, even fighting tooth and nail for that since the founders are invested. they are also more likely to keep hanging on to staff, not shedding them left and right every other fiscal quarter.
    lastly they seem more likely to bounce back from the grave as a reformed company should the business ever hit a wall.

    i could think of some independent european studios providing dozens or hundreds of jobs which would have surely vanished a long time ago had they ever succumbed to a buyout offer and found themselves unlucky enough to work on some under-performing project.
  • skyline5gtr
    Offline / Send Message
    skyline5gtr polycounter lvl 9
    doc rob wrote: »
    There's a lot of wrong people in this thread.

    1) EA was nothing but good to Mythic. It's been 6 years since WAR came out - 6 YEARS - and Dungeon Keeper was the only thing to come out of the studio in that time to generate revenue. How do you think Mythic stayed afloat that long? EA could have shut it down at any time and kept the live MMOs going with a small crew. EA tried for 6 years to allow Mythic to reinvent itself as a studio, and Dungeon Keeper shows that it was finally getting there.

    2) Dungeon Keeper was a success. For all the hardcore gamer hate, the people that game was actually for, liked it and continue to play it. It's a successful game. Check the app annie gross charts trend if you don't believe me.


    uhm average critic score is 4.2 average user is .3 - how is that a success ? The people hat play are a small small percentage
  • aesir
    Offline / Send Message
    aesir polycounter lvl 18
    thomasp wrote: »
    i'd argue independently run places have more of an incentive to keep the business running, even fighting tooth and nail for that since the founders are invested. they are also more likely to keep hanging on to staff, not shedding them left and right every other fiscal quarter.
    lastly they seem more likely to bounce back from the grave as a reformed company should the business ever hit a wall.

    i could think of some independent european studios providing dozens or hundreds of jobs which would have surely vanished a long time ago had they ever succumbed to a buyout offer and found themselves unlucky enough to work on some under-performing project.

    Yea that's true they might hang on tooth and nail, yet at the same time, they often don't have the resources of a large publisher to keep self funding after launching a poor game.
  • NegevPro
    Offline / Send Message
    NegevPro polycounter lvl 4
    uhm average critic score is 4.2 average user is .3 - how is that a success ? The people hat play are a small small percentage
    Well to be fair, most successful F2P games rely on cash whale consumers that spend large amounts of money in little time. If DK has such low scores, then that would indicate the non-cash whale players, the people who actually care about fair prices, are non-existent. If the game itself is fun then some rich people (or crazy people?) won't care if they are spending a couple hundred dollars for a few hours of fun.
  • skyline5gtr
    Offline / Send Message
    skyline5gtr polycounter lvl 9
    people really spend that much money on little useless games like that ? , wow i learned something
  • Wesley
    Offline / Send Message
    Wesley polycounter lvl 13
    I only spend my money on the most useful games. Like those that teach me life lessons.
  • NegevPro
    Offline / Send Message
    NegevPro polycounter lvl 4
    I'll spend money on any game that interests me or any game that is really fun, but I try to limit my purchases. For F2P games I tend to only pay for the ones that are really well made, like BLR, Nosgoth, Everquest, etc. as it helps support the devs and encourages them to keep improving the game.

    Many people however, buy as much as they can in a game for little reason. Just look at some of the popular Asian F2P games, many of them are fairly "generic" in the sense that they bring nothing new to the table. Many are poorly balanced in the sense that somebody who spends even $1 has a huge advantage over somebody who plays for free, and many are ripoffs of each other.

    This mindset isn't exclusive to Asia either. If you look at Valve's F2P games (or their semi-F2P games), you'll see there are people who end up spending thousands of dollars over their glorified gambling system. I recall reading a thread about how much money people spent on keys in Counter-Strike:Global Offensive and while the average user spent under $50, there were many people who spent a couple of hundred dollars, and even a handful of people that spent a few thousand, all over the course of maybe 6 months.

    There's a lot of psychology to back up the F2P model but I think a lot of people end up purchasing items in order to feel like they have something that nobody else does. In Counter-Strike, knife skins are very rare and many of them sell for a few hundred dollars on the marketplace because of how rare they are, since the only way to get them other than paying for them on the marketplace is to open crates with keys (that cost $2.49 each), many people tend to make a purchase in hopes of winning the lottery.

    The funny thing about the CSGO example is the fact that the alpha of the game actually contained the premium knife skins as starter content, but the beta and final release of the game removed the items and replaced them with higher quality assets. The knives that are so valuable are just re-textured alpha assets. So it's not even a question of "Are people paying for higher quality content?"

    At the end of the day, a person can do what they want with their paycheck, though.
  • Justin Meisse
    Offline / Send Message
    Justin Meisse polycounter lvl 18
    F2P hate can be boiled down to people who don't like it and/or don't understand it so they say it's going to fail. Like arcade developers when consoles starting becoming popular.
  • ambershee
    Offline / Send Message
    ambershee polycounter lvl 17
    People hate it because they don't like it - there's some sound reasoning there..

    I don't like it, because it is often implemented in a way that is legitimately anti-consumer, such as the sale of completely intangible items that exist purely for the purposes of being sold ($90 'bucket of gems' in Dungeon Keeper? What's that about?). I don't know if the model is going to survive long-term, but I want to see it at least regulated. Casinos, online and offline are strictly regulated, but Valve are left to do whatever they like with their crate systems.
  • LRoy
    Offline / Send Message
    LRoy polycounter lvl 10
    ambershee wrote: »
    Casinos, online and offline are strictly regulated, but Valve are left to do whatever they like with their crate systems.

    This is a terrible comparison.
  • ambershee
    Offline / Send Message
    ambershee polycounter lvl 17
    How is it a terrible comparison? Gambling is gambling - in an online casino you're playing for virtual items you can trade for cash and Valve's crates you're playing for virtual items you can trade for cash..
  • NegevPro
    Offline / Send Message
    NegevPro polycounter lvl 4
    I really like F2P, I play a lot of games that are both "balanced" and "unbalanced" although I rarely, if ever make a purchase if the game appears to be "unbalanced." I love the idea of having hundreds, if not thousands of new games to play without having to spend a penny, and many of them are also very fun. It encourages developers to focus on making a kickass game simply because at the end of the day, I can choose which games I'd like to support without having to risk getting screwed out of a $60+ purchase.

    Also, I don't think comparing Valve's crate system to gambling is too far off. A lot of people buy into the system simply because of the opening animation in CSGO. I've spent about $15 on keys because every time I open a crate, it feels like I'm closer to unboxing a knife simply because the animation makes it seem that way. In reality an item is selected at random from a list that is controlled by Valve's pre-determined drop percentages. If they wanted to make the ugliest skin in the game become the most valuable, they could do it overnight.

    Valve gets more people to buy in with the low cost of keys ($2.49 as opposed to many other games which force you to buy in-game currencies in bundles) and it's readily available to kids too.

    In Valve's games, you can sell your crates on the marketplace with 15% of the profits made going right back into Valve's pocket. At some point you'll have enough to purchase keys, and rather than saving the money to buy a new game or some extra content, you'll frequently see people put that money back into the game through keys because like gambling, unboxing crates is fun.

    If you don't believe me, just look at some of the videos on youtube where people are unboxing hundreds of crates in a single go. More popular youtubers/streamers will end up relying on donations because they themselves don't want to waste money on this crap, but like I said, there are also many people who are addicted to this.

    I'm not fully against the crate system. If Valve found a legal way to make money without ruining my own experience, good for them, but I wish there was at least a warning or something to help the addicts. I also love the fact that they allow community members to submit content that can be monetized.

    The current state of submitting content for CSGO basically amounts to painting random bright colors on the UV sheet of a weapon (I saw somebody just use the UV sheet as a skin before lol), submitting it to the workshop, then spamming everybody who has a Steam account with your workshop link in hopes that they'll give it a thumbs up. I believe Valve released a pointpoint presentation on this, but for some reason people prefer having their guns look like plastic toys rather than fitting the military/realistic theme of the game.
  • Muzzoid
    Offline / Send Message
    Muzzoid polycounter lvl 10
    EDIT: posted a redundant thing because i didn't refresh my page.
  • Justin Meisse
    Offline / Send Message
    Justin Meisse polycounter lvl 18
    I just played Dungeon Keeper - amazing work guys, it's a shame 99% of all the people bashing it never even downloaded the app. If you're going into it for the first time, compare it to Clash of Clans, collectively called "Battle Games". Maybe if us mobile devs continue to just make Battle Games for the next 20 years we'll get the same respect devs who make Doom-clones.... cough cough, I mean First Person Shooters.
  • ZacD
    Offline / Send Message
    ZacD ngon master
    The problem is Dungeon Keeper is nothing like the original Dungeon Keeper games, if they renamed it "Dungeon Keeper: Battle" Or something, it'd be a bit more acceptable. Also if you rate the app 5 stars in the app, it posts the review in the store, you rate it 1-4 stars in the app, it asks you to send a email, and it doesn't post the score to the play store.

    If you want to play a Dungeon Keeper game, War For The Overworld is an actual spiritual successor.

    Battle Games play like cow-clickers + sit and wait games, which are hardly games.
  • Justin Meisse
    Offline / Send Message
    Justin Meisse polycounter lvl 18
    ZacD wrote: »
    Battle Games play like cow-clickers + sit and wait games, which are hardly games.

    You're welcome to your own opinion but they made a good game, if they were independent they could continue making mobile games and make a steady income.
  • Torch
    Offline / Send Message
    Torch interpolator
    To anyone reading this thread, you have the option to wait 24 hours to see how it ends... Or you can pay us an extortionate fee and view it straight away :D
  • ExcessiveZero
    Offline / Send Message
    ExcessiveZero polycounter lvl 6
    ambershee wrote: »
    How is it a terrible comparison? Gambling is gambling - in an online casino you're playing for virtual items you can trade for cash and Valve's crates you're playing for virtual items you can trade for cash..

    I think its a valid comparison, in japan gambling for money is illegal or something so they get round it by gambling for tokens or balls that can be traded for money/prizes.

    same system essentially, but this whole line of discussion is sort of derailing the thread.
  • eld
    Offline / Send Message
    eld polycounter lvl 18
    You're welcome to your own opinion but they made a good game, if they were independent they could continue making mobile games and make a steady income.

    It's been generally and universally acclaimed as not only a bad follow up but an actual bad experience on top of something that could've been promising. It's a prime example of paywalling gone too far.

    This is not an attack on the work gone into that game, this is an attack on the choices that made it into what it ended up like.

    i-4cwmVJt-1050x10000.jpg
  • Justin Meisse
    Offline / Send Message
    Justin Meisse polycounter lvl 18
    eld wrote: »
    It's been generally and universally acclaimed as not only a bad follow up but an actual bad experience on top of something that could've been promising. It's a prime example of paywalling gone too far.

    What level is your Dungeon Heart? I fell for the bad press myself until I remembered that gamers love to hate & dogpile on a percieved flaw. Try it out and then try out the current blockbuster juggernaut that is Clash of Clans. Compare & contrast.

    Look, you can dislike F2P games but the constant cries for regulation or predicting failure is pretty tiring.

    I don't know if any Mythic people who lost their jobs are reading this, don't worry. All this hate mirrors the Warhammer hate when I got laid off, luckily the people in charge of hiring recognize great work.
  • eld
    Offline / Send Message
    eld polycounter lvl 18
    What level is your Dungeon Heart? I fell for the bad press myself until I remembered that gamers love to hate & dogpile on a percieved flaw. Try it out and then try out the current blockbuster juggernaut that is Clash of Clans. Compare & contrast.

    That would've required me to play further than I wanted to, hitting paywalls just for wanting to dig walls isn't a fun experience in a game like dungeon-keeper.

    The amount of time and amount of money you have to pay to progress something will only escalate, and the numbers are exponential, not linear.
    Look, you can dislike F2P games but the constant cries for regulation or predicting failure is pretty tiring.

    I don't, free to play games are great, dwarf fortress is my favorite one, didn't cost my but a voluntary donation!

    Jokes aside though, I can't say I hate free to play games, there are some fantastic examples out there like TF2 or DOTA 2, and that's how I picture good free to play games.
    I don't know if any Mythic people who lost their jobs are reading this, don't worry. All this hate mirrors the Warhammer hate when I got laid off, luckily the people in charge of hiring recognize great work.

    Which is the separate issue, I've myself been involved far too many times with big teams putting fantastic work and talent into projects that in the end were bad games because of a few chosen but important things.

    I still have my WAR collectors edition on the shelf, I enjoyed that one. I think I've already mentioned what the big shame is: That promising franchises like Ultima and dungeon keeper ended up in the big free to play graveyard on the app-market.

    And to say that these titles were big hits contradicts EA's decision to close down mythic.
  • Justin Meisse
    Offline / Send Message
    Justin Meisse polycounter lvl 18
    eld wrote: »
    That would've required me to play further than I wanted to, hitting paywalls just for wanting to dig walls isn't a fun experience in a game like dungeon-keeper.

    That's odd, I haven't hit a paywall at all, digging out the soft low level stone is 12 seconds for your goblins. A pay wall is a hard stop that requires you to pay to progress any further. When it suggests you spend a gem to speed them up, you've already got a starting bank of gems to spend. Since you've got no intention of paying, just burn through those gems :P. I tend to conserve them. These aren't games that you sit down and do 5 hour marathon sessions, I typically check my Battle Command base in the morning before I go to work and do some PvP when I get home and I can see myself doing the same in Dungeon Keeper.
    eld wrote: »
    Jokes aside though, I can't say I hate free to play games, there are some fantastic examples out there like TF2 or DOTA 2, and that's how I picture good free to play games.

    It's funny you mention that, I've always considered the mystery box drop that you have to pay to open as a bit dirty.
    eld wrote: »
    And to say that these titles were big hits contradicts EA's decision to close down mythic.

    They were successes, a studio of 100 people could get by on it but when it's part of EA's 9,000 employees it's not bringing in the giant, Simpsons Tapped Out money bags they require. The bright side is, F2P mobile games currently don't need big publishers. The game industry has been relying on the AAA blockbuster or bust model for so long nobody even recognized when the middle came back.

    I hope we get to see the core of Mythic mobile reform as a new independent studio, it's still like the old days of development where you can make a low cost, low risk mobile game to pay the bills and fund something new.
  • ZacD
    Offline / Send Message
    ZacD ngon master
    It's funny you mention that, I've always considered the mystery box drop that you have to pay to open as a bit dirty.

    Optional cosmetic packs are hardly dirty compared to other games. Games like League of Legends lock most of the characters behind a pay/time wall. You'll either have to put in about 8 hours or pay for a character. Other games do similar things with gun and equipment unlocks. Also doesn't Dota and TF2 give out a lot of free cosmetic items?
  • Justin Meisse
    Offline / Send Message
    Justin Meisse polycounter lvl 18
    I'll stop trying to promote f2p games, if you guys avoid it that means less competition for us :P.

    Anyway, when my layoff condalances thread got turned into a anti-mmo warhammer sucks thread it really made me angry and generated negative opinions of many polycounters that took years to wear off, so maybe we should stop being absolute shit heads and derailing this thread into an armchair analysis of why Mythic got shut down.
Sign In or Register to comment.