Looking for feedback on several dota items

Replies

• 
  Options

  Offline / Send Message

  danee

  Jun 2015

  Please help me~
  Really need opinions~

  0 · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
• 
  Options

  Offline / Send Message

  Vayne4800 polycounter lvl 3

  Jun 2015

  Aren't you the one who posted with DAC2015 nickname? Are you affiliated with them? As for the items, half of them look great.

  0 · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
• 
  Options

  Offline / Send Message

  danee

  Jun 2015

  Just partnership.
  Thanks for your reply!
  I will refine them according to your opinion.

  0 · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
• 
  Options

  Offline / Send Message

  HeadCrabD

  Jun 2015

  danee wrote: »

  Just partnership.
  Thanks for your reply!
  I will refine them according to your opinion.

  
  
  id like to refine the "Azureant" would you? just send me the concept. i can remodel them

  0 · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
• 
  Options

  Offline / Send Message

  danee

  Jun 2015

  HeadCrabD wrote: »

  id like to refine the "Azureant" would you? just send me the concept. i can remodel them

  
  sorry but I have a partner who helps me modeling，I cant fire him:(
  I will appreciate if you could give me advice！

  0 · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
• 
  Options

  Offline / Send Message

  Potm keyframe

  Jun 2015

  im not sure if you are DAC2015 , or another person who is partnership with him....but
  
  
  im always a fan with your drawing (the one who drew the design), you have amazing amazing art, like the Mirana set in game with that loading screen, i love it so much and wish to have it someday.
  
  HOWEVER, you also ruined Mirana with the model you made, im a mirana lover, and im not happy with how it ends up. the quality of the model is lacking, as well as the texture.
  
  and this apply to the mirana mount u have made in this list, the drawing and concept looks nice and well done, but once becomes in 3d version, it is just so bad ;(

  0 · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
• 
  Options

  Offline / Send Message

  danee

  Jun 2015

  Potm wrote: »

  im not sure if you are DAC2015 , or another person who is partnership with him....but
  
  
  im always a fan with your drawing (the one who drew the design), you have amazing amazing art, like the Mirana set in game with that loading screen, i love it so much and wish to have it someday.
  
  HOWEVER, you also ruined Mirana with the model you made, im a mirana lover, and im not happy with how it ends up. the quality of the model is lacking, as well as the texture.
  
  and this apply to the mirana mount u have made in this list, the drawing and concept looks nice and well done, but once becomes in 3d version, it is just so bad ;(

  
  
  Thank you so much
  we will refine the 3dmodel of the mirana mount!

  0 · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
• 
  Options

  Offline / Send Message

  Godzy polycounter lvl 6

  Jun 2015

  Mirana mount - the whole concept is a bit lacking (Considering how many other great mirana mounts have been added over time, this one doesn't stand out at all). The model doesn't look that great either but that wouldn't be the main problem with it imo.
  
  Treants - I honestly like the idea behind those but the textures are a bit lacking as well. The leafs blend in too much with the rest of the body (and imo some particle wouldve looked better than the current leafs)
  
  Ward - I like the design overall but i think it would look too small ingame (can't really say exactly since you didn't add any game view shots)
  
  Tide Bottle - It would've been nice if it had some suble/creative particles with it
  
  Tide Hat - too noisy/pointy for my tastes. silhouette could be ok i guess
  
  Qop Dagger - Personally i feel that the dagger slot is the least interesting slot she has. Unless you are going to do something nice and unique for her, it's going to end up as "another small dagger that nobody will notice"
  
  Necro Weapon - same as the mirana mount. i would rather replace than fix this one
  
  Morph Back - great silhouette but: http://dota2.gamepedia.com/Luminary_of_the_Dreadful_Abyss_Set
  
  Lion Head - Looks ok. If i had any complain on it i would say that the model is kinda flat
  
  Jug Head - Reminds me of the old jug heads. the biggest problem about it is that the spikes which were supposed to pop out the silhouette blend in too much with the fur
  
  CK Weapon - Nothing spectacular
  
  Doom Wings - Really poor execution. It might also be a bit noisy on the flaming bits but the biggest flaw would be the model itself
  
  Es Totem - Looks ok but I think the UV could've been a lot better. The textures don't look that sharp (and the guy has 512x256 texture res damnit)
  
  Kunkka Stick - I find it a bit pointless tbh
  Sven Sword - Not sure what to say about this one. It's not on my favorite list but its not completely bad either
  
  Slardar hat - nope
  
  
  I didn't vote because I don't like hidden results.

  0 · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
• 
  Options

  Offline / Send Message

  danee

  Jun 2015

  Godzy wrote: »

  Mirana mount - the whole concept is a bit lacking (Considering how many other great mirana mounts have been added over time, this one doesn't stand out at all). The model doesn't look that great either but that wouldn't be the main problem with it imo.
  
  Treants - I honestly like the idea behind those but the textures are a bit lacking as well. The leafs blend in too much with the rest of the body (and imo some particle wouldve looked better than the current leafs)
  
  Ward - I like the design overall but i think it would look too small ingame (can't really say exactly since you didn't add any game view shots)
  
  Tide Bottle - It would've been nice if it had some suble/creative particles with it
  
  Tide Hat - too noisy/pointy for my tastes. silhouette could be ok i guess
  
  Qop Dagger - Personally i feel that the dagger slot is the least interesting slot she has. Unless you are going to do something nice and unique for her, it's going to end up as "another small dagger that nobody will notice"
  
  Necro Weapon - same as the mirana mount. i would rather replace than fix this one
  
  Morph Back - great silhouette but: http://dota2.gamepedia.com/Luminary_of_the_Dreadful_Abyss_Set
  
  Lion Head - Looks ok. If i had any complain on it i would say that the model is kinda flat
  
  Jug Head - Reminds me of the old jug heads. the biggest problem about it is that the spikes which were supposed to pop out the silhouette blend in too much with the fur
  
  CK Weapon - Nothing spectacular
  
  Doom Wings - Really poor execution. It might also be a bit noisy on the flaming bits but the biggest flaw would be the model itself
  
  Es Totem - Looks ok but I think the UV could've been a lot better. The textures don't look that sharp (and the guy has 512x256 texture res damnit)
  
  Kunkka Stick - I find it a bit pointless tbh
  Sven Sword - Not sure what to say about this one. It's not on my favorite list but its not completely bad either
  
  Slardar hat - nope
  
  
  I didn't vote because I don't like hidden results.

  
  
  Thank you so much!
  You are awesome！

  0 · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
• 
  Options

  Offline / Send Message

  danee

  Jun 2015

  Potm wrote: »

  im not sure if you are DAC2015 , or another person who is partnership with him....but
  
  
  im always a fan with your drawing (the one who drew the design), you have amazing amazing art, like the Mirana set in game with that loading screen, i love it so much and wish to have it someday.
  
  HOWEVER, you also ruined Mirana with the model you made, im a mirana lover, and im not happy with how it ends up. the quality of the model is lacking, as well as the texture.
  
  and this apply to the mirana mount u have made in this list, the drawing and concept looks nice and well done, but once becomes in 3d version, it is just so bad ;(

  
  http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=450831314
  how about the refine one?

  0 · Share on FacebookShare on Twitter