Home 3D Art Showcase & Critiques

Vehicle texturing

Hello all,

This is my first vehicle to texture and I'm kinda not happy with it at all.
It's currently "crap" and it needs to become "good".

The concept:

Untitled-1839fa.jpg

What I have:

3a0b42.jpg


This is on a tight deadline so any help is really appreciated.
Thanks a lot.

Replies

  • Youngy798
    Options
    Offline / Send Message
    Youngy798 polycounter lvl 4
    It doesn't look crap. I think you should emphasize the colours a bit more, make them stand out. At the moment it all kind of looks a silvery-grey colour.
  • billymcguffin
    Options
    Offline / Send Message
    billymcguffin polycounter lvl 11
    Are you using metalness or spec workflow? If you're using spec, I think the reflectance of the paint is too high at the moment. Try looking at it with different backgrounds as well.
  • marcobar
    Options
    Offline / Send Message
    marcobar polycounter lvl 4
    I agree with Youngy, one thing that would elevate the texture right off the bat is an interesting assortment of colour, something you can clearly see in your concept. I would also be a bit more careful with the scale of the details you're adding to the texture. The dent inside of the right-most engine looks almost like it's been put under a magnifying glass.

    It would also be helpful to post an image of your unwrap in the thread, so that people can see how you've packed everything. There are some parts that could easily be overlapped, giving you more space for the parts that are "front and center" on the hull.
  • Maximum-Dev
    Options
    Offline / Send Message
    Thank you all for the feedback.

    The other problem is the low quality of the texture. It's a 2k map but still the metal scratches are so blurry.

    111.jpg

    22222.jpg

    Almost in all games vehicles use 2k textures and are so high quality than what I'm having here. Are the UV's above packed wrong?
  • Swarm22
    Options
    Offline / Send Message
    Swarm22 polycounter lvl 15
    Well, you want to give more UV space to areas that are most important. Having everything on your UV's 1-1 scale with the model isn't the best idea for getting the most out of your UV space.
  • Deathstick
    Options
    Offline / Send Message
    Deathstick polycounter lvl 7
    You also have to keep in mind that a vehicle in comparison to say, a person, has ALOT more square footage hence a space vehicle thats 10-20 times as big as a person is going to look a lot more low res up close than a person at the same distance, if both are using say one 2k texture map each.

    You could migrate this factor by splitting your UVs/textures into multiple 2k textures for your ship, ie one for the cockpit and centerpiece, one for the side engines and details, etc.

    I'd say it's not uncommon for vehicles to be split into multiple textures, especially if you want to maintain detail in say a first-person perspective.


    And then there's always tiling textures to keep in mind, which is another solution for being able to have crisp detail up close for objects that are building size and up+

    The X-series for example has a lot of different types and sizes of ships, from tiny little fighters to massive 40+ fighter carriers, and they make use of having multiple tiling materials on basically all of their different types of ships + space stations. (At least in x3: tc/ap) I'm not sure exactly on X-rebirth since I only played it for a couple of hours, but I'm pretty sure it's the same method but with a higher-resolution, advanced shaders, and a change in art-direction.

    That said, I'd say your vehicle probably could just be split into two or three 2k textures to up the resolution while maintaining unique surface details, since it seems about fighter size/bigger than a car but smaller than a tugboat.

    You also might consider having flipped/overlapped UVs if you haven't already, which is another way to up the resolution for larger objects like vehicles while trying to keep a relatively small texture size. IE dividing the ship down the middle and having it basically be a texture map with one half mirrored to the other side. You'll just have to be extra careful of causing a potential seam in the middle, and make sure your game engine supports flipping normals. (I believe Unreal engine 3 and 4 do) You'll also definitely want a second UV channel for things like lightmaps if you're doing any overlapping on your UV's. You can even get a little more advanced with using tiling textures by having the tiling textures in channel 1 of the UVs, and baking out an AO/dirt map using the unique uv set from channel 2 and having it multiply on top. Usually shadowmaps or anything ao related don't really need as a high a resolution as color maps since they basically are just defining dark areas, which are usually inherently blurry anyways.

    So yeah, there's multiple ways on having crisper resolutions for objects larger than a humanoid but all rely on having good UVs that make the most out of their space. (well, except tiling textures, since those UVs are usually all over the place)

    Each one does come with its own sacrifice though so it's up to you. (more unique details vs basically infinite ability on size without blurring up close, symmetrical details versus mutiple texture maps, possibility of having a tough time with the mirrored seam if using normals, etc.)

    And of course there's also things like "detail maps" which are just repeating diffuse/normal/etc textures that are faded in and blended on top of the object's actual texture/materials when getting close to the object. I don't really use them personally but they can be good for adding a little more detail up close such as grit/noise in the metal/porous rocks/extreme closeup skin details/etc

    https://docs.unrealengine.com/latest/INT/Engine/Rendering/Materials/Functions/Reference/Texturing/index.html#detailtexturing

    I hope that helps somewhat in your consideration beyond making the UVs a bit more compact.
  • Deathstick
    Options
    Offline / Send Message
    Deathstick polycounter lvl 7
    On the discourse of the actual texturing elements themselves, you can probably do a few more passes rather than just having an overall color per-element, the noise of the material, and the damage normals. Try messing around with adding in an ambient occlusion map either in its own slot if you're doing PBR, or multiplied on top of the color map if you're working traditionally.

    You can also do things like have the scratches and damage values different in the specular or roughness map, and mess around with the metallic value if going the metalness workflow (UE4) route.

    Additional elements such as grebble/metal paneling and plating/bolts can be added in photoshop using something like xnormal filter or ndo. And then for the final touches you can add in some actual "paint" work such as strips of color and graphic design work (think hotrods, racecars, bomber plane paint, typography, warning panels, pull here to eject cockpit shield, this slides ->, arrows, flammable, sign work, warning explosive bolts, turboengine mk1 Serial0001337, etc.) which could be put on top of your color map in photoshop using the overlay, color, or multiply layer style with tweaked opacity. (would let some of the surface detail pass through the paint job)
  • alex1111
    Options
    Offline / Send Message
    alex1111 polycounter lvl 9
    Using multiple textures like what deathstick mentioned is a good idea. If you can't do that for this project, I recommend normalizing your UV's so that the larger surfaces get more pixels and packing your uvs more tightly.
  • thatdude02
    Options
    Offline / Send Message
    Copy and merge all you layers and then add a sharpen modifier to that layer. Helped me out a lot in school.
  • Maximum-Dev
    Options
    Offline / Send Message
    @Swarm22, Thank you for the feedback.

    @alex1111, Appreciated. UVs reworked.

    @thatdude02, I usually forget to take advantage of sharpening the texture. Thanks a lot for reminding.

    @Deathstick, Sir, Thank you for the very helpful and detailed feedback. You helped me a lot on this. :)

    That's the result.

    j4aFTi8.jpg
  • GrungyStudios
    Options
    Offline / Send Message
    GrungyStudios polycounter lvl 8
    Nice wear and tear but focus on those edges my man
Sign In or Register to comment.