Reply
Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
unnamed1800's Avatar
Old (#1)
Here is a paint over I just did of a lion I drew. Any feedback/critique is greatly appreciated, thanks in advance.
Offline , null, 20 Posts, Join Date Nov 2011, Location currently pennsylvania  
   Reply With Quote

Isaiah Sherman's Avatar
Old (#2)
That poor fella needs some food! Maybe using a thicker brush would help him feel better. Also, when you use a green tint to shade on something fleshy colored, it makes it look undead.
There is always more to learn.

Portfolio: http://www.shermanCG.com
Email: shermanCG@gmail.com

Digital Matte Artist @ Bungie
Offline , polycounter, 1,197 Posts, Join Date Sep 2008, Location Seattle, WA  
   Reply With Quote

ZacD's Avatar
Old (#3)
I'm not the greatest concept artist around, but you need to get rid of those dark lines, use bigger brushes, and focus more on the lighting.

Offline , polycounter, lvl. 13, 7,244 Posts, Join Date Jul 2009, Location Columbus Ohio Send a message via MSN to ZacD  
   Reply With Quote

SiegePerilous's Avatar
Old (#4)
I'm also not a great concept artist but maybe I can help.

1. Right now it looks like your color scheme is one area you could easily improve. Your shadows are currently just darker value versions of your base color. And you have a lot of black in your shadows. This is causing it to feel washed out and dead.

Your shadows should be the complementary color of your light source as you get darker (yellow light = purplish shadows, red light = greenish shadows). I find I like the results I get when I move away from my base color toward the complementary color as I get to darker and darker areas.

2. I would suggest a unified color scheme for the entire creature or even painting. Right now your hair looks great but since the body doesn't have the same color scheme it looks disconnected. I did some paintovers with what I thought were better colors but I still wasn't too happy with the results until I started pulling colors from the hair itself. Then it started to feel much more unified.

Here's an example of colors I pulled directly from your hair. And below that an example of my and your schemes side by side so you can see how much more integrated having a unified color scheme feels.





* my color scheme is laid out on the left and yours is laid out on the right

After sampling the colors from the hair I simply painted over a greyscale version of your lion.

If you check the Color Picker and use the eyedrop tool you can see how much more saturated my shadows and those of your hair are than the shadows you are now using on the body and face.

Last edited by SiegePerilous; 02-28-2012 at 01:52 AM..
Offline , line, 63 Posts, Join Date Sep 2011, Location Redmond, WA  
   Reply With Quote

unnamed1800's Avatar
Old (#5)
I really appreciate the feedback, I took what both of you said about my colors and made it a little more vibrant. I Apologize if I missed some of the green that I have in the paint, Im a bit color-blind. But I'm still working on it.
Offline , null, 20 Posts, Join Date Nov 2011, Location currently pennsylvania  
   Reply With Quote

Isaiah Sherman's Avatar
Old (#6)
That's definitely a step forward!
There is always more to learn.

Portfolio: http://www.shermanCG.com
Email: shermanCG@gmail.com

Digital Matte Artist @ Bungie
Offline , polycounter, 1,197 Posts, Join Date Sep 2008, Location Seattle, WA  
   Reply With Quote

unnamed1800's Avatar
Old (#7)
Thank you!, I will definitely be posting some more progress asap!
Offline , null, 20 Posts, Join Date Nov 2011, Location currently pennsylvania  
   Reply With Quote

Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Copyright 1998-2012 A. Risch